Introduction: Discovering that your newly purchased car is a lemon can be a frustrating and stressful experience. Fortunately, California lemon laws provide consumers with legal protections and remedies in such situations. But what if you want to keep your car despite its lemon status? Can you lemon your car and still retain ownership? As a California lemon law lawyer, I encounter clients with this question frequently. In this article, I’ll provide insights into whether it’s possible to lemon your car and keep it, along with the implications and considerations involved.
Understanding Lemon Laws in California: Before delving into the possibility of lemoning your car and keeping it, it’s essential to understand lemon laws in California. These laws are designed to protect consumers who purchase or lease defective vehicles, often referred to as “lemons.” The California Lemon Law, also known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, provides legal remedies for consumers who find themselves with a lemon.
Under the California Lemon Law, if a vehicle has a substantial defect covered by the manufacturer’s warranty that impairs its use, value, or safety, and the manufacturer fails to repair the defect after a reasonable number of repair attempts, the consumer may be entitled to relief. This relief may include a refund of the purchase price or lease payments, a replacement vehicle, or cash compensation.
Can You Lemon Your Car and Still Keep It? While lemon laws typically provide consumers with the option to return the vehicle to the manufacturer in exchange for a refund or replacement, there may be circumstances where consumers wish to keep the vehicle despite its lemon status and accept a cash settlement in lieu of a buy back. In some cases, consumers may have developed an attachment to the vehicle, or they may be willing to tolerate its defects if the manufacturer provides compensation or resolves the issues to their satisfaction.
In California, it is possible to go through the process of lemoning your car and still retain ownership of your car, but here are some considerations and implications to keep in mind:
1. A Cash Settlement Means You Will Still Owe Your Loan on the Car: If you wish to settle your lemon law case against the manufacturer for a cash settlement just know that this does not mean that the manufacturer will pay off your car loan in conjunction with the cash you negotiate. You will still be obligated on that loan. You can, of course, use the cash you receive to reduce the loan amount if you choose.
2. Make sure your Warranty Terms Remain the Same: Typically, in a cash settlement type situation, your warranty on the vehicle will remain in place and will continue on as it would have before you filed a lawsuit or negotiated a cash settlement directly with the manufacturer.
3. Extended Warranty or Repair Coverage: In some cases, manufacturers may offer extended warranty coverage or additional repair assurances to consumers who choose to lemon their vehicles and keep them. This can provide peace of mind for owners concerned about ongoing maintenance and repair costs related to the vehicle’s defects.
4. Legal Documentation: When negotiating with the manufacturer to lemon your car and keep it, it’s essential to document all communications, agreements, and resolutions in writing. This includes detailing the terms of any compensation or extended warranty coverage offered by the manufacturer, as well as any obligations or responsibilities on the part of the consumer.
5. Consumer Protection: It’s important for consumers to be aware of their rights under the California Lemon Law and other consumer protection laws. While lemoning your car and keeping it is an option, consumers should ensure that they receive fair and adequate compensation for their lemon vehicles and that their rights are protected throughout the process.
Conclusion: While lemoning your car and keeping it is possible in California, it requires negotiation with the manufacturer and careful consideration of the implications and considerations involved. Consumers who choose this option should be prepared to advocate for fair compensation for their lemon vehicles and ensure that they receive adequate assurances regarding ongoing repairs and maintenance. Consulting with a qualified lemon law lawyer can provide valuable guidance and assistance in navigating this process and protecting your rights as a consumer. A lawyer can also do the negotiating for you to potentially maximize your cash recovery.
Lemon Law Lawyers Group
32605 Temecula Parkway
Suite 101, Temecula, CA 92592
Phone: (951) 324-4111
Fax: (951) 602-6520
[email protected]
Contact Us
Send message
Live chat
Schedule meeting
Disclaimer
The founder and owner of Lemon Law Lawyers Group, Inc. is Erika N. Kavicky, State Bar No. 225052. This website does not create an attorney client relationship nor does it provide legal advice. Any results posted on the website are not guarantees, warranties, or predictions on how your case may turn out. This website is intended for legal advertisement as allowable by the California State Bar.
To Buy or Not to Buy: Understanding Service Contracts When Purchasing a New Car
Introduction: Purchasing a new car is an exciting experience, but it can also come with its fair share of decisions and considerations. One such decision often presented to buyers is whether or not to invest in a service contract offered by the dealer. As a California...
Understanding the Importance of Giving Manufacturers a Reasonable Number of Repair Opportunities for Your New Car Under Warranty
Introduction: Purchasing a new car is an exciting milestone for many consumers. However, when a new vehicle experiences persistent issues or defects, it can quickly turn into a frustrating and disappointing experience. Fortunately, consumers in California are...
Choosing a Lemon-Proof Car: Insights from a California Lemon Law Lawyer
Introduction: The prospect of buying a new car is both thrilling and daunting. On one hand, you're excited about the possibilities of hitting the road in a shiny, reliable vehicle. On the other hand, there's always that nagging worry: What if I end up with a lemon? As...
What Happens After the Manufacturer Buys Back Your Lemon
Introduction: Discovering that your newly purchased vehicle is a lemon can be a frustrating and disappointing experience. Fortunately, California lemon laws provide consumers with legal protections and remedies in such situations. If your vehicle qualifies as a lemon...